Mod Doll Monday, (July 20th - 27th, 2015) Who Models It Best?

Hi everyone,

[The Contest has ended - and the winner was: Patty G. ... and the Caroline Doll. Thanks everyone for entering!]

Welcome to week two of our Mod Doll Monday giveaways! The question is simple: who models it best? You vote to help us decide and one lucky participant will receive the winning doll as well as the Limited Edition Liberty Jane Outfit. The winner will be selected at random on Monday, July 27th, and notified within 48 hours.

More About Each Doll:

American Girl® Doll: Beforever Caroline Abbott: Caroline hails from the early 1800's with aquamarine eyes and golden blond hair. She comes with her original outfit, the book Captain Of The Ship, and original box. Retail Value: $115

American Girl® Truly Me™ #62: With beautiful straight dark brown hair, brown eyes, and medium skin tone, this cute Truly Me™ doll is newly released for 2015. Doll also comes with original Truly Me™ booklet, outfit and box. Retail Value: $115

More About The Limited Edition Liberty Jane Clothing Outfit: Iced caramel macchiato, please! The girls will be here in five....  Radiant Orchid is the color of the year and we've got a beautiful outfit featuring this pop of color, perfect for a day at the cafe! The reversible Peleton Muscle tank in two varying shades, a deep fushia and a lighter orchid purple, is made from silky sift knits! It's layered over a cute bandeau and paired with a grey and white stripe maxi skirt beautifully mitered in the front and back for a unique look! The top features enclosed seams and a tiny button loop closure. The skirt has a fold over yoga style waist band and slips on and off easily. Outfit includes black flip flops. The outfit is designed to fit 18 inch dolls such as American Girl or Madame Alexander. Retail Value: $36

Vote Now & Enter To Win: There are multiple ways to enter. The only required entry method is voting to help us decide who models it best. The doll with the most votes will be given away with the Limited Edition Liberty Jane Outfit. One person will receive one of the dolls and the outfit. You can enter once, or gain multiple entries by completing the other entry methods, and increase your chances of winning. Please review all Terms and Conditions on the giveaway page before entering. While we wish we could run this contest everywhere, for legal reasons it is only open to eligible residents of the U.S. and Canada, not including Rhode Island. This contest is exclusively endorsed by Liberty Jane Clothing. Not associated with American Girl® Doll.

a Rafflecopter giveaway

More pictures of each doll:

 

We'd love to know what you think. Leave a comment below and tell us which one you hope will win. 

Thanks everyone,

Cinnamon


100 Comments

Linda K
Linda K

July 20, 2015

Beautiful outfit I vote for Caroline

Carole
Carole

July 20, 2015

the outfits are identical so it must be the blond hair. I vote for Caroline

Donna
Donna

July 20, 2015

Caroline!

Echo
Echo

July 20, 2015

I think Caroline is best love her long blonde hair

linda holder
linda holder

July 20, 2015

Caroline gets my vote.

Patsy
Patsy

July 20, 2015

The color of the outfit was beautiful, both looked wonderful but, my first granddaughter has the eye and hair color of Caroline.

Judy VanMaldeghem
Judy VanMaldeghem

July 20, 2015

Caroline looks amazing!

Helen Diane Evans
Helen Diane Evans

July 20, 2015

Caroline and she should always wear pinks!

Laura T.
Laura T.

July 20, 2015

Both dolls look very pretty in the outfit, but my vote is for Caroline. I love how the pink compliments her eyes and wavy blonde hair.

Joan
Joan

July 20, 2015

Blonde hair runs in my family…love the long, blonde tresses, reminds me of my children after a summer in the sun!

Anne
Anne

July 20, 2015

Truly Me all the way! Those colors just pop against her darker skin! Also she’s prettier.

Rhiannon
Rhiannon

July 20, 2015

I vote Truly Me #62. I love her hair and skin tone with that pink top!

Genevieve Jezick
Genevieve Jezick

July 20, 2015

Truly Me has the coloring for the vibrant color top… she has my vote

Kim F
Kim F

July 20, 2015

I love this outfit on Caroline!

sandy
sandy

July 20, 2015

I think that truly me wins this vote, she looks the best in the style and colors.

Debbie C
Debbie C

July 20, 2015

Cute outfit! I vote for Caroline.

Larissa Creighton
Larissa Creighton

July 20, 2015

I think these colors look better on the doll with dark hair truly me 62

Debbie Honsowetz
Debbie Honsowetz

July 20, 2015

The colors just pop on Truly me 62. She gets my vote.

Billir R.
Billir R.

July 20, 2015

I would choose Caroline. She looks like my grand daughter that I sew for. Would love to have her for myself. 84 yrs old and still love dolls!Love your patterns and this is such a generous thing you are doing. Good luck to all!

Deborah
Deborah

July 20, 2015

I think truly me 62 rocks that outfit! It just compliments her eyes. But Caroline looks just as adorable in it as well. But truly me 62 rocks it more.

Tracy Jones
Tracy Jones

July 20, 2015

Truly Me #62 looks best in these colors. She is standing straighter and showing off the outfit better. Her coloring looks wonderful in these colors. Caroline looks very pale in comparison.

Jos
Jos

July 20, 2015

Caroline definitely gets the vote on this one. The pinks in the outfit top compliment her hair, skin tone and eye color.

sandie
sandie

July 20, 2015

I Love both dolls, but I will vote for Caroline. Her wavy hair is so pretty. Thank you

Stephanie
Stephanie

July 20, 2015

Caroline gets my vote!

Melanie
Melanie

July 20, 2015

Tough choice! Truly Me #62, with her gorgeous face…and Caroline, a beautiful runner up!

Melinda
Melinda

July 20, 2015

Truly Me #62 got my vote, but Caroline is adorable too.

Nancy
Nancy

July 20, 2015

Caroline, I just love that blonde hair, just like me great granddaughter. She models the clothes the best.

Terrie
Terrie

July 20, 2015

This week, I’d have to say Caroline is the winner1 she’s beautiful with her long wavy blonde hair!

Jane W
Jane W

July 20, 2015

The colors look best on Truly Me #62. While both dolls can wear it, Carolyn is overwhelmed by the bright color. On Truly Me, you see the doll and the outfit as equals.

Laurie
Laurie

July 20, 2015

I vote for Caroline! So pretty in pink!

mary ann
mary ann

July 20, 2015

the outfit is beautiful on either doll, however, the dark coloration divides your eye between hair/face color and the bright top…on Caroline the blonde allows the garment to be seen first….I vote Caroline….

Clara Hughes
Clara Hughes

July 20, 2015

Truly Me is my choice. But Caroline is cute but not my choice

CeeJay
CeeJay

July 20, 2015

Caroline – love those colors on her. Her hair and skin set off the orchid top best.
I do love the dark chevrons of the skirt with Truly Me’s hair color but I think she needs a brighter top.

Cherish
Cherish

July 20, 2015

Truly Me!

Barbie
Barbie

July 20, 2015

Love this great outfit on Truely Me!

Milinda Southard
Milinda Southard

July 20, 2015

I love Truly Me 62. She is beautiful in that color, because of the dark complexion.

Pat
Pat

July 20, 2015

Love how the fushia with Caroline’s blonde hair makes the outfit look so fresh for this hot summer!

Carole
Carole

July 20, 2015

Both are so cute. But I have to go with Truly Me #62, since she reminds me so much of my beautiful Granddaughter!!!

Kathie
Kathie

July 20, 2015

Truly me

Isabella
Isabella

July 20, 2015

I voted for #62: The colors pop on her skin, and Caroline has wonky eyes, heheh.

Sarah
Sarah

July 20, 2015

Caroline gets my vote!

Sonya Hemmings
Sonya Hemmings

July 20, 2015

Caroline is the clear contender for me! Adorable outfit!

Diana Evans
Diana Evans

July 20, 2015

The blonde hair with green eyes just had to be the one! The dark hair and brown eyes is very pretty.

Colleen Murphy
Colleen Murphy

July 20, 2015

I like the hot pink on Caroline.

Jan York
Jan York

July 20, 2015

Love Truly Me’s gorgeous eyes and chestnut hair! She is a winner this week! Caroline is a pretty runner-up!

Diana
Diana

July 20, 2015

BeForever Caroline, hers eyes sparkle and she seems to smile, the green eyes seem to draw the color of the skirt out. She looks so happy and that smile makes you want to smile with her.

Jennifer
Jennifer

July 20, 2015

Caroline for sure! The pink looks so amazing with her blond hair and eyes.

Mary Pelkey
Mary Pelkey

July 20, 2015

I love the outfit on Truly Me #62.

Tracy
Tracy

July 20, 2015

I think it fits Truly Me #62 the best. The top lays better across her chest and it also fits at the abdominal area best on Truly Me. I love the colors on Truly Me. However I believe fit is more important than color.

CAROL M
CAROL M

July 20, 2015

Caroline is the doll for me. Love her.

Vicky
Vicky

July 20, 2015

Truly Me is rocking this outfit! But all by itself this outfit is just smashing. So cute!

Judy Sillyman
Judy Sillyman

July 20, 2015

Caroline

Lori Straley
Lori Straley

July 20, 2015

definately Caroline. That pink makes her blue eyes and blond hair glow.

Valeri vejrostek
Valeri vejrostek

July 20, 2015

I would have to pick Caroline because , and don’t laugh , she looks like I did at the original Woodstock ! And here I am , still playing with dolls .

Lian
Lian

July 20, 2015

Caroline!

Ruth
Ruth

July 20, 2015

Cute outfit on either…..but if I have to choose I’d say Caroline.

Marilyn P.
Marilyn P.

July 20, 2015

My vote goes to Caroline!

TJ
TJ

July 20, 2015

Truly Me 62 with her dark skin tones against the bright colors looks stunning!

Deb
Deb

July 20, 2015

My vote is for Truely Me

Judith Epstein
Judith Epstein

July 20, 2015

Beforever Caroline Abbott. Her coloring look sbetter with the outfit. On the other doll I only see her dark hair, not the outfit.

Charla
Charla

July 20, 2015

Looks great on both dolls, but I thought the pink really popped against Caroline’s pale skin and blonde hair!

Katie
Katie

July 20, 2015

Caroline looks amazing!

Donna
Donna

July 20, 2015

Truly Me doll #64 is gorgeous!

Maria
Maria

July 20, 2015

Truly Me, for sure.

J
J

July 20, 2015

Beforever Caroline Abbott:

Vickie Warburton
Vickie Warburton

July 20, 2015

Truly me #62

Celine Jolie
Celine Jolie

July 20, 2015

Personally, both dolls model the outfit beautifully as they are both gorgeous as well is the outfit and it’s versitality. But, the delicate yet vibrant colors in the outfit go quite well in my opinion with combination of skin, hair, and eyes on the Truly Me model. :)

D.M.
D.M.

July 20, 2015

Not an easy choice to make! Both Caroline and Truly Me #62 look beautiful in the outfit. As to who wore it best, I would have to choose TM #62.
The rich, soft lavender top and stripped maxi skirt bring out a wonderful exotic look with this doll!

Debbie
Debbie

July 20, 2015

Caroline gets my vote. I love the magenta top with her soft blonde curls.

Carolyn
Carolyn

July 20, 2015

Truely Me #62 looks great with the outfit.

Annette
Annette

July 20, 2015

Truly me’s tan skin color really compliments the color of this outfit

Roylene Neal
Roylene Neal

July 20, 2015

I favor a doll with dark hair but Caroline is getting my vote this time she is rocking the outfit!

Martha
Martha

July 20, 2015

Truly me for sure.

Tana Steward
Tana Steward

July 20, 2015

Truly me #62 is my favorite. Her skin and hair are a wonderful contrast to the sweet outfit.

Nancy Mierau
Nancy Mierau

July 20, 2015

Caroline’s beautiful long wavy hair is the best choice with the deep fuschia
and radiant orchid colors chosen for this beautiful ensemble. The dark hair of Truly Me would be better suited to brighter colors, perhaps even neon shades, in my humble opinion. Thanks for asking. Nancy

Cali
Cali

July 20, 2015

Truly Me #62.

Dottie Baker
Dottie Baker

July 20, 2015

Loving Caroline!

Barbara Lipovics
Barbara Lipovics

July 20, 2015

I think Caroline wears it best. She looks just like a little girl I know with long blonde curls. Although the colors look really nice on the other doll, Caroline sparkles in this outfit!

Jenny L
Jenny L

July 20, 2015

I vote for Truly me, but they both look nice.

Ann
Ann

July 20, 2015

Sweeeeeet Caroline!!!

Veronica cummings
Veronica cummings

July 20, 2015

I voted for Caroline.

Narda Weber
Narda Weber

July 20, 2015

Both dolls look great in this outfit, but I am voting for Truly Me!

Klara
Klara

July 20, 2015

I like Caroline better.

Erin
Erin

July 20, 2015

Well I took it to the experts. My two girls who are obsessed with AG dolls.
The vote is split. My youngest loves Caroline and my older daughter loves #62!!
So I will break the tie and go with #62.
But as usual your outfits ate beautiful!!

Norma Betz
Norma Betz

July 20, 2015

I vote for Caroline

Lorraine M
Lorraine M

July 20, 2015

Both are adorable and as much as I love Carolyn’s blonde curls, Truly 62 really shines with her dark hair and eyes. Truly 62 makes the colors more vibrant! I would love to win either of these dolls as they are so sweet!

Pam R.
Pam R.

July 20, 2015

The outfit looks great on both, but Caroline has a stereotypical California look that fits the style of the outfit.

Lori
Lori

July 20, 2015

I think Caroline looks beautiful in the outfit

Jolene
Jolene

July 20, 2015

I like this outfit on truly me :) She is beautiful

Elaine W
Elaine W

July 20, 2015

I think Truly Me #62 looks best in those colours. She is obviously a “winter” and those are her colours.

Elna
Elna

July 20, 2015

Truly Me 62! Love her dark hair and the striped skirt! But really, both are adorable!

Hilary Catron
Hilary Catron

July 20, 2015

Miss Caroline resembles my daughter and my younger granddaughter. We love that color of pink!

Marty
Marty

July 20, 2015

Truly Me 62 looks better in hot pink!

Emily
Emily

July 20, 2015

I love the outfit on Caroline! So cute!

Patricia Clark
Patricia Clark

July 20, 2015

Have to go with Truly Me on this one. She just ‘blooms’ in this outfit.

Cathy
Cathy

July 20, 2015

Love the look on Caroline! Cute outfit looks great with the curly hair!!!

Terry
Terry

July 20, 2015

Caroline with her long curly hair looks best in the outfit.

Charlotte Volkman
Charlotte Volkman

July 20, 2015

I agree with one of the ladies that the colors do “pop” better on Caroline, besides, my grandmothers name was Caroline, nickname “Carrie”. So I bought Caroline for my granddaughter. She has the same color hair and eyes.

Annette
Annette

July 20, 2015

Truly me’s tan skin color really compliments the color of this outfit

Julie Barlocher
Julie Barlocher

July 20, 2015

Caroline is my choice for this week. Both dolls look great in this summery outfit though.

Leave a comment