Mod Doll Monday, (July 20th - 27th, 2015) Who Models It Best?

Hi everyone,

[The Contest has ended - and the winner was: Patty G. ... and the Caroline Doll. Thanks everyone for entering!]

Welcome to week two of our Mod Doll Monday giveaways! The question is simple: who models it best? You vote to help us decide and one lucky participant will receive the winning doll as well as the Limited Edition Liberty Jane Outfit. The winner will be selected at random on Monday, July 27th, and notified within 48 hours.

More About Each Doll:

American Girl® Doll: Beforever Caroline Abbott: Caroline hails from the early 1800's with aquamarine eyes and golden blond hair. She comes with her original outfit, the book Captain Of The Ship, and original box. Retail Value: $115

American Girl® Truly Me™ #62: With beautiful straight dark brown hair, brown eyes, and medium skin tone, this cute Truly Me™ doll is newly released for 2015. Doll also comes with original Truly Me™ booklet, outfit and box. Retail Value: $115

More About The Limited Edition Liberty Jane Clothing Outfit: Iced caramel macchiato, please! The girls will be here in five....  Radiant Orchid is the color of the year and we've got a beautiful outfit featuring this pop of color, perfect for a day at the cafe! The reversible Peleton Muscle tank in two varying shades, a deep fushia and a lighter orchid purple, is made from silky sift knits! It's layered over a cute bandeau and paired with a grey and white stripe maxi skirt beautifully mitered in the front and back for a unique look! The top features enclosed seams and a tiny button loop closure. The skirt has a fold over yoga style waist band and slips on and off easily. Outfit includes black flip flops. The outfit is designed to fit 18 inch dolls such as American Girl or Madame Alexander. Retail Value: $36

Vote Now & Enter To Win: There are multiple ways to enter. The only required entry method is voting to help us decide who models it best. The doll with the most votes will be given away with the Limited Edition Liberty Jane Outfit. One person will receive one of the dolls and the outfit. You can enter once, or gain multiple entries by completing the other entry methods, and increase your chances of winning. Please review all Terms and Conditions on the giveaway page before entering. While we wish we could run this contest everywhere, for legal reasons it is only open to eligible residents of the U.S. and Canada, not including Rhode Island. This contest is exclusively endorsed by Liberty Jane Clothing. Not associated with American Girl® Doll.

a Rafflecopter giveaway

More pictures of each doll:

 

We'd love to know what you think. Leave a comment below and tell us which one you hope will win. 

Thanks everyone,

Cinnamon


100 Comments

Karen Wagner
Karen Wagner

July 21, 2015

I think it looks best on the Truly Me doll. The top seems to fit her better.

Melody
Melody

July 21, 2015

It’s a tough choice, but I have to go for BeForever Caroline. :)

Tamara G
Tamara G

July 21, 2015

They both look truly darling in the outfit, but I think my pick would be for the Truly Me doll. The colors are a lovely contrast to her hair and skin tone. So cute!

Gerri F
Gerri F

July 21, 2015

Have to go with Caroline. That outfit was made for her!

Loretta
Loretta

July 21, 2015

Truly Me gets my vote. The colors of the outfit are more complimentary for dark hair and her skin tone.

Lesli
Lesli

July 21, 2015

I like truly me in the outfit but Caroline looks great to my toe is for truly me

Betsey Mann
Betsey Mann

July 21, 2015

Oops! Caroline!

Linda
Linda

July 21, 2015

Both girls are very prettyI think Caroline is so beautiful with her blue eyes and long curly hair.

Vickie Graham
Vickie Graham

July 21, 2015

Truly me wears it best.

Betsey Mann
Betsey Mann

July 21, 2015

Too hard to pick! Had to do eeny meeny money moe!!!

Ellen
Ellen

July 21, 2015

Caroline!

Rosie Armstrong
Rosie Armstrong

July 21, 2015

I really love both dolls, but I think that the coloring looks better on Caroline. It seems to look brighter on her. What a hard decision! Both dolls look adorable.

Gloria Barnett
Gloria Barnett

July 21, 2015

They both look nice but I think Caroline will win

Elizabeth Coates
Elizabeth Coates

July 21, 2015

I am a avid seamstress and love the way these colours compliment our dark haired model. They brighten her beautiful brown eyes. Such a super little outfit, makes her ready for a wonderful day. Thank you for the opportunity to vote.

Ellen
Ellen

July 21, 2015

I like Caroline the best. Her long blonde hair and beautiful blue eyes look very “California Girl” and go so well with the outfit.

Natalie
Natalie

July 21, 2015

I like both, but I think the color of this top looks better with Caroline’s skintone.

jane koob
jane koob

July 21, 2015

vote is for Caroline, although both dolls are beautiful.

Donna
Donna

July 21, 2015

I vote for Caroline—- but both are so adorable!

Haylee
Haylee

July 21, 2015

I absolutely love the outfit you picked out for the models to wear. If I had to choose which one modeled it best it would have to be Caroline. Her long blonde hair goes beautifully with the maroon tink top. Her eyes go great with the striped long skirt and it just all goes well together that is the reason why Caroline modeled it best!

Jerry Coats
Jerry Coats

July 21, 2015

YEA 62! She looks so comfortable in her outfit, ready to enjoy the cookout and bask in the sunshine. Bring on the moon with lots of stars to go with a laidback evening. Come what may, she is dressed to be at ease as well as chic.

Mary Zurn
Mary Zurn

July 21, 2015

I love the way the outfil looks on Truely Me. She makes it stand out with her coloring. Love it!

Marian-sergerlady
Marian-sergerlady

July 21, 2015

I love the purple on Caroline…Such a beautiful color for her blonde hair, reminds me of my sister when she was small…Her hair was the same color and my mother used to wear this color on her…

Shanita Armand
Shanita Armand

July 21, 2015

I like both, they are adorable. Since I have to choose it will be truly me #62.

Carol Fulton
Carol Fulton

July 21, 2015

Caroline’s beautiful wavy hair really compliments the outfit

Cheryl
Cheryl

July 21, 2015

Truly Me # 62 is my vote, she has that tanned look that makes that outfit sparkle. She is stunning in this summer outfit and her skin complexion and dark hair against that pink makes a fashion statement. I am carefree and ready for a nice smoothie as I go meet my friends for some afternoon fun.

Gisi
Gisi

July 21, 2015

Truly Me #62 is a very nice looking doll

Sandra Chavez
Sandra Chavez

July 21, 2015

While both are just cute as can be, I thought that Truly Me! showed off the bright pink color of the top the best.

Bobbi Cummings
Bobbi Cummings

July 21, 2015

I like number 62. She really looks goodin those colors.

Carrie
Carrie

July 21, 2015

I love them both but I voted for caroline also. Will we get to pick which doll we want from American girl if we win? As my daughter really wants the new doll “Grace” that came out last week, although I am sure she would be super happy with one of these also. :) and her birthday is in a couple weeks and I would love to surprise her with her if we won :) Thank you :)

Sally
Sally

July 21, 2015

While I think both dolls look nice in this summery outfit, the darker complexion, hair, and eyes of Truly Me #62 really sets it off. She’s got my vote.

Elaine Hoffman
Elaine Hoffman

July 21, 2015

I would love to see Beforever Caroline win this challenge because she looks so natural wearing this outfit like a butterfly on a Summer’s Day. This outfit would be great at the beach, at a barbeque cookout and catching butterflies. Her long blonde hair with ringlets falling gently on each side of her face, looks so beautiful and innocent in this modern fashion ensemble. Her sandals are even appropriate for the occasion as well. Very nice looking doll wearing this beautiful outfit for Summertime.

Carol Osborn
Carol Osborn

July 21, 2015

Caroline gets my vote. Both are beautiful.

CAROLE
CAROLE

July 21, 2015

Both outfits look great but Caroline is the one

Barbara Sell
Barbara Sell

July 21, 2015

Caroline by far!

Alexia
Alexia

July 21, 2015

I would love to win grace tomS

Libby H
Libby H

July 21, 2015

The Truely Me doll looks great in this outfit- Caroline is cute to but #62 looks wonderful !

Theresa
Theresa

July 21, 2015

I believe Caroline wears the outfit the best.

Linda
Linda

July 21, 2015

I think Caroline is the best. she has my vote.

Sharon
Sharon

July 21, 2015

Truly me, her dark hair suits it better.

Joanne
Joanne

July 21, 2015

Caroline!

Cris
Cris

July 21, 2015

I love the bright pink with Truly Me’s dark hair.

Barbara Johansen
Barbara Johansen

July 21, 2015

I think the pink goes really nicely with Caroline’s blonde hair and fair complexion.

Gloria Twiggs
Gloria Twiggs

July 21, 2015

Caroline looks so much like my Grand Darlin Moira with the same eye and hair color. Also she likes these tops.

Marie
Marie

July 21, 2015

I love the pink on Caroline. Both are lovely.

Vi Lawson
Vi Lawson

July 21, 2015

Think Caroline is a beautiful Doll, and the outfit looks pretty on her

Cookie
Cookie

July 21, 2015

I vote for Caroline, she just looks more carefree and comfortable in her beautiful outfit.

Mariam R.
Mariam R.

July 21, 2015

Caroline wears it better. The pink in the tank top looks better with her blonde hair. #62 is beautiful too.

Pam
Pam

July 21, 2015

Both girls look lovely in pink, but I think Truly Me #62 looks positively Hawaiian in the outfit. I vote for her!

Nina
Nina

July 21, 2015

The dark hair and complexion of Truly Me #62 makes the pink pop. I like her best.

Judith
Judith

July 21, 2015

Caroline’s blond hair looks better with the bright colt of the top

Kate
Kate

July 21, 2015

I think Caroline’s cascading curls provide a lovely contrast to the bright colors of the outfit

Monique
Monique

July 21, 2015

I think that Truly Me with her dark complexion has a sharper look and I vote for her….

Irene
Irene

July 21, 2015

Both dolls look very nice in the outfit. I like the sweet expression on Caroline. She looks like she is very proud to be wearing the outfit.

Dottie
Dottie

July 21, 2015

Everyone of the Dolls are just perfect no matter the clothing!! Caroline is my favorite because of the beautiful long blond curls and the beautiful green eyes—she looks sweet 16 and ready for a date with prince charming!!

Bart
Bart

July 21, 2015

I like Caroline better

Connie
Connie

July 21, 2015

Love Caroline, her beautiful blonde hair and aqua marine eyes are saying please take me home.

Whitney Jacobs
Whitney Jacobs

July 21, 2015

Both are beautiful, but I voted for Caroline because she is the American Doll my granddaughter has and the one for whom I sew! Thanks for all you do, both here and abroad.

Nel
Nel

July 21, 2015

I like them both but I like Caroline’s hair better and how well it goes with the outfit….

Annie
Annie

July 21, 2015

I love the Caroline complexion and hair color with the bright raspberry top. She gets my vote! !

Leah M.
Leah M.

July 21, 2015

has my vote!
Abigail
Abigail

July 21, 2015

I like them both and even though Truly Me’s complexion looks better with the pink shirt, I like Caroline better because of how the outfit looks with her hairstyle. Both the outfit and the hairstyle seem perfect for the beach and give her a relaxed summer look.

Cassandra Andrus
Cassandra Andrus

July 21, 2015

Although both beautiful I prefer Truly Me #62 in the outfit.

cynthia
cynthia

July 21, 2015

I chose Truly Me, only because I had to choose one. Blondes are generally head-turners for the men. We brunettes get short changed at times.

C.P.
C.P.

July 21, 2015

Both are very pretty! I’m going to vote Caroline because she looks bright and happy in this lovely outfit.

Trish
Trish

July 21, 2015

I vote for Caroline! I think the chevron design of the maxi skirt, the boho style of the tank top and Caroline’s blonde ringlets all generate a mod yet contemporary vibe! I love the pink with black/white color combo too. Thank you for the chance! Trish

Rebecca
Rebecca

July 21, 2015

Beautiful on both dolls, but Truly Me tops Caroline just a tad. Truly Me shines in the strong pink of the top causing both doll and outfit to pop!

Bonnie
Bonnie

July 21, 2015

Truly Me, as the pink goes with her complection better.

Fran
Fran

July 21, 2015

TRULY ME is the best.

Blue
Blue

July 21, 2015

Again, both dolls are lovely. Truly Me #62 gets my vote this week.

Emma
Emma

July 21, 2015

i think caroline looked better in this outfit her eyes just gave the outfit that pop of color

Carol
Carol

July 21, 2015

Please, please, please let Kelly Pilkinton win this doll for her little African American friend. Her entry is so thoughtful, generous and considerate of someone who would truly appreciate having a doll of her own and perhaps go on to develop sewing skills. Nothing i could say can top that heartfelt entry, and her appreciation and compliments to Cinnamon and her company. I feel that entry represents most of all, what Pixie Faire’s giving spirit is all about. May God bless everyone!

Brenda
Brenda

July 21, 2015

Truly Me looks gorgeous. I vote for her!

Barbara Haring
Barbara Haring

July 21, 2015

I go with what strikes me at first and I think Truly Me pulls off the outfit smashingly. And I love the tone of her skin and her beautiful dark eyes.

Dorothy Raatz
Dorothy Raatz

July 21, 2015

Truly Me should be the winner, she wears the outfit really well.

Emma
Emma

July 21, 2015

Definitely #62. I’m in love with this doll anyway and she looks great in this outfit.

Dorisanne Osborn
Dorisanne Osborn

July 21, 2015

The vibrant colors of the magenta top look great on both girls, but I think it looks best on Truly Me #62.

Laura C
Laura C

July 21, 2015

Well, really? They are both adorable !! But I’m into color and I think the dark pink looks perfect on the darker skin of Truly Me and the black stripe in the skirt coordinates nicely with the dark hair, HOWEVER, the long blonde ringlet go great with the 60’s thing that is this ensemble. So I have to vote TRULY ME.

Carol
Carol

July 21, 2015

Caroline, with her blonde hair and gorgeous eyes (am a blonde myself and very partial to Caroline), she looks beautiful and so classy right down to her sandals. However, my eyes travel to Truly Me (#62) easily. Truly Me seems as if she is in Hawaii, ready to meet her friends for a lovely time together. Truly Me is stunning in this outfit with her dark hair, velvet eyes, lovely skin tone – the outfit compliments her in all respects. Truly Me wears it best!

Linda Vee
Linda Vee

July 21, 2015

I vote for Truly Me. She looks swishy in those colors. They match her complexion.

Marian
Marian

July 21, 2015

I adore Caroline’s beautiful blonde hair with this bright top. #54 is a beautiful doll but this time I had to give Caroline my vote before she is discontinued.

Betty
Betty

July 21, 2015

Coloring more matches Truly Me.

Laura
Laura

July 21, 2015

Truly Me 62 looks beautiful in this outfit. The magenta is very complementary to her skintone! Love this outfit!

Katherine
Katherine

July 21, 2015

Truly me 62 for the win! I don’t like the bright color with Caro’s eyes. I think they clash a bit. I love the coloring of Truly Me 62 with these colors, though.

Abigail
Abigail

July 21, 2015

caught my attention because the milky brown eyes and black hair goes better with the outfit than Caroline with the blue-green eyes and blonde hair.
Carol A
Carol A

July 21, 2015

I believe Truley Me #82 looks better – probably because I like the dark haired dolls.

Dianne
Dianne

July 21, 2015

Another vote for Caroline!

dana
dana

July 21, 2015

Definitely truly me #62

Jackie
Jackie

July 21, 2015

I think truly me #62 looks best.

Karin
Karin

July 21, 2015

I vote for Caroline

Louise
Louise

July 21, 2015

Love Caroline—-looks like my Sarah.

Pat
Pat

July 21, 2015

Truly Me gets my vote. I love that her outfit colors pop against her black hair and darker complexion.

Sandra
Sandra

July 21, 2015

I think Caroline modeled the outfit best. Her blonde hair was a pretty contrast to the colors in the great outfit.

Sue
Sue

July 21, 2015

I think Caroline is lovely in the outfit, the person who made the skirt did a wonderful job of matching the stripes in the skirt.

Renee
Renee

July 21, 2015

Caroline

Becky
Becky

July 21, 2015

Truly Me wears it just a bit better. The colors are great on her.

Frannie
Frannie

July 21, 2015

I really like Caroline, but the Truly Me #62 is gorgeous too. I think Caroline wins!

Michelle Lamm
Michelle Lamm

July 21, 2015

I love Caroline. Love her hair and eyes.

crystal
crystal

July 21, 2015

I love Caroline. She ’s such a pretty doll. Love her wavy hair & green eyes.

Donna Landreth
Donna Landreth

July 21, 2015

I think Truly Me doll models it better because of her dark hair. It looks better with the pink top and black striped skirt.

Anita Boelke
Anita Boelke

July 21, 2015

Truly Me #62 should win , the colors of the outfit suits her skin tone very much …

« Previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 14 Next »

Leave a comment