Mod Doll Monday, (July 20th - 27th, 2015) Who Models It Best?

Hi everyone,

[The Contest has ended - and the winner was: Patty G. ... and the Caroline Doll. Thanks everyone for entering!]

Welcome to week two of our Mod Doll Monday giveaways! The question is simple: who models it best? You vote to help us decide and one lucky participant will receive the winning doll as well as the Limited Edition Liberty Jane Outfit. The winner will be selected at random on Monday, July 27th, and notified within 48 hours.

More About Each Doll:

American Girl® Doll: Beforever Caroline Abbott: Caroline hails from the early 1800's with aquamarine eyes and golden blond hair. She comes with her original outfit, the book Captain Of The Ship, and original box. Retail Value: $115

American Girl® Truly Me™ #62: With beautiful straight dark brown hair, brown eyes, and medium skin tone, this cute Truly Me™ doll is newly released for 2015. Doll also comes with original Truly Me™ booklet, outfit and box. Retail Value: $115

More About The Limited Edition Liberty Jane Clothing Outfit: Iced caramel macchiato, please! The girls will be here in five....  Radiant Orchid is the color of the year and we've got a beautiful outfit featuring this pop of color, perfect for a day at the cafe! The reversible Peleton Muscle tank in two varying shades, a deep fushia and a lighter orchid purple, is made from silky sift knits! It's layered over a cute bandeau and paired with a grey and white stripe maxi skirt beautifully mitered in the front and back for a unique look! The top features enclosed seams and a tiny button loop closure. The skirt has a fold over yoga style waist band and slips on and off easily. Outfit includes black flip flops. The outfit is designed to fit 18 inch dolls such as American Girl or Madame Alexander. Retail Value: $36

Vote Now & Enter To Win: There are multiple ways to enter. The only required entry method is voting to help us decide who models it best. The doll with the most votes will be given away with the Limited Edition Liberty Jane Outfit. One person will receive one of the dolls and the outfit. You can enter once, or gain multiple entries by completing the other entry methods, and increase your chances of winning. Please review all Terms and Conditions on the giveaway page before entering. While we wish we could run this contest everywhere, for legal reasons it is only open to eligible residents of the U.S. and Canada, not including Rhode Island. This contest is exclusively endorsed by Liberty Jane Clothing. Not associated with American Girl® Doll.

a Rafflecopter giveaway

More pictures of each doll:

 

We'd love to know what you think. Leave a comment below and tell us which one you hope will win. 

Thanks everyone,

Cinnamon


100 Comments

Kathy
Kathy

July 20, 2015

This week both girls look quite stylish in their maxi skirts, but I would have to say that Truly Me wears the outfit better. The pink top flatters her beautiful dark hark hair and sun kissed complexion!

Natalie
Natalie

July 20, 2015

Definitely the Truly Me doll! Modern clothes for modern girls!

Marie
Marie

July 20, 2015

I vote for Caroline. She looks free and easy it that outfit! She’s ready for a fun time with friends.

Arlene
Arlene

July 20, 2015

Truly Me #62 wears the outfit much better than Caroline.

deidra
deidra

July 20, 2015

Caroline for sure.

Kathy G.
Kathy G.

July 20, 2015

I love Caroline.

Crystal
Crystal

July 20, 2015

I think that Truly Me looks better in it because it reminds me of outfits worn by exotic, beautiful Spanish girls in movies, and the Truly Me doll looks like that.

Sandy G
Sandy G

July 20, 2015

Truly Me#62 looks better in pink so I vote for her!

Liz Webster
Liz Webster

July 20, 2015

Truly Me is the one for me.

Gillian
Gillian

July 20, 2015

I made the maxi skirt for each of my granddaughters. It was a wonderful pattern to work with. I choose Caroline to win because one of my granddaughters has Caroline and loves her dearly.

Cindy M
Cindy M

July 20, 2015

The Truly Me gets my vote this week. Contests to last weeks winner and a BIG thank you to Liberty Jane and Pixie Faire for all the awesome things they do for their customers

cristina
cristina

July 20, 2015

I Like the outfit more on Truly Me #62

Julie
Julie

July 20, 2015

While I know nothing about colors, I know what I like better.
Truly Me 62 seems to wear the colors and outfit with more style.

In a different outfit, I would most likely choose Carolne. Really, it is difficult to go wrong!

Desiree
Desiree

July 20, 2015

I like Truly Me # 62 because I think that her darker color looks better with this type of pink. Caroline’s color looks pale in comparison to # 62.

Franike Rossouw
Franike Rossouw

July 20, 2015

Caroline lols like my daughter. She’s got my vote

kena
kena

July 20, 2015

Truely Me #62 is totally rocking this beautiful Maxi skirt on this runway accented with a beautiful top and adorable sandals. Her beautiful skin tone, hair and eye color really stands out very nice with the colors chosen for the outfit today.

Pat
Pat

July 20, 2015

I vote Caroline

Linda Wernette
Linda Wernette

July 20, 2015

The rich color of #62 compliments the two tone raspberry colored top she has on.

Susan
Susan

July 20, 2015

Caroline looks like she’s ready to go to a block party or a concert in the park. The pink in the outfit highlights her blonde hair and aquamarine eyes!

Cindy Talbott
Cindy Talbott

July 20, 2015

Truly Me gets my vote, so cute on her.

Melanie
Melanie

July 20, 2015

Caroline gets my vote. But, they are both cute!

carol m
carol m

July 20, 2015

The darker doll wears it best, but Caroline is stylin’ too!

Kellie
Kellie

July 20, 2015

Such a hard decision to make but I picked Truly Me doll.. It just seemed to flow better on her and all the colors made it pop!

Sherry
Sherry

July 20, 2015

I like it on Truly Me. The pink is beautiful with her dark hair.

Autum
Autum

July 20, 2015

I’d have to go with Caroline. The pink really suites her!

Susan Rees
Susan Rees

July 20, 2015

I vote for Carolyn. She shines in this outfit.

Dana Bradley
Dana Bradley

July 20, 2015

I like Caroline, I am partial to blondes. She looks good in pink! Dana

Candice
Candice

July 20, 2015

Truly me 62 looks better. She doesn’t get washed out with the colors.

Deanna T.
Deanna T.

July 20, 2015

I like how Truly Me wears the outfit…it just looks good on her.

Sandy
Sandy

July 20, 2015

Truly me looks the best in this outfit, the colors just go better with the darker completion. Very cute!

Victoria
Victoria

July 20, 2015

Caroline looks beautiful in her maxi skirt and top! She looks like a ray of sunshine on a summer day! I love the colors and goes great with her hair and skin tone. So I pick Caroline for week two!

Isabel
Isabel

July 20, 2015

There look great but Caroline looks better

Isabel
Isabel

July 20, 2015

There look great but Caroline looks better

Tamalyn
Tamalyn

July 20, 2015

My eyes are drawn to caroline. She looks to be a very pretty doll. Her blond hair stands out next to the top. So my vote goes to Caroline.

Joan Richardson
Joan Richardson

July 20, 2015

This is a tough choice, but I think Caroline looks better in this outfit

Ann
Ann

July 20, 2015

They are both so cute, but as a blonde myself with blond girls and grand daughters, I think I’m partial to Caroline!

designdreamer
designdreamer

July 20, 2015

BeForever Caroline

Becky
Becky

July 20, 2015

With such a powerful pop of color for a top, this outfit is best suited for a girl who isn’t overshadowed by bold designs & colors. With her tanned skin, brown eyes, and silky dark hair, Truly Me is as eye-catching as her outfit! I think we have a winner!

linda dunnihoou
linda dunnihoou

July 20, 2015

Truly Me gets my vote!

Dianne
Dianne

July 20, 2015

As a adult I would wear thus with little black top that cover my arms. bt love the look on both dolls was hard to decide which was better. Have a Bless Week Thanks Dianne from SC

Natalie O
Natalie O

July 20, 2015

They’re both cute. I like Caroline’s wavy hair, it adds to the summer look. :)

sharon gaston
sharon gaston

July 20, 2015

truly me #62 looks better than carolyn.

Sharon
Sharon

July 20, 2015

Truly Me #62 models the best.

Candace
Candace

July 20, 2015

Caroline rocks the outfit!!

Virginia Short
Virginia Short

July 20, 2015

After looking at both dolls closely, I vote for the truly me doll. The colors of the outfits really look very beautiful against her beautiful skin color.

Jo Ann Rutledge
Jo Ann Rutledge

July 20, 2015

Truly Me #62 looks like my “new” granddaughter..SO my vote is #62…. She would love it. My daughter still has her doll, and I loved making the clothes for hers. I now have a 9 year old step grand daughter, who is dying to make doll clothes. Thank you so much for the patterns to help me help her.

Jolynne
Jolynne

July 20, 2015

Caroline

Susan
Susan

July 20, 2015

They are both wicked cute but Caroline gets my vote on this one!

Wendy
Wendy

July 20, 2015

Hands down Caroline!

Irene
Irene

July 20, 2015

Love Caroline!

Marjory W.
Marjory W.

July 20, 2015

I love it on Truly Me #62, as the bright color is such a beautiful contrast to her skin, hair and eyes. The stripes go with her hair, as well.

Bev
Bev

July 20, 2015

Caroline

Virginia
Virginia

July 20, 2015

Caroline looked like the real Mod Doll in that Chevron skirt.

A. Zamudio
A. Zamudio

July 20, 2015

Truly Me looks great in this outfit! The color contrast with her hair makes it so striking.

Bonnie
Bonnie

July 20, 2015

I think truly me #62.

Pam
Pam

July 20, 2015

Caroline – it looks better with her skin.

Tara
Tara

July 20, 2015

Truly Me #62, I love the colors with her skin and hair color.

Heather McLaughlin
Heather McLaughlin

July 20, 2015

I think the pink top sets of Caroline’s wavy blond hair. She gets my vote.

Lynn Hull
Lynn Hull

July 20, 2015

I love the outfit best on Caroline Abbot. She’s so cute and blonde. The eye color is so neat as they described…

Lynn

Moi Mid
Moi Mid

July 20, 2015

Caroline — coincidently she looks soooooo much like my granddaughter!!

Rhondda F
Rhondda F

July 20, 2015

I think these colours and style look stunning on the Truly Me .

Marjorie
Marjorie

July 20, 2015

Truly Me has my vote!

LOIS
LOIS

July 20, 2015

blonde hair and the color pink are a good combination. I vote for Carolyn.

Carol B
Carol B

July 20, 2015

Love the outfit on Caroline!

Brenda
Brenda

July 20, 2015

Love them both! Caroline looks beautiful with her curls but the colors do look great on the Truly me Doll #62.
Tough choice!

Susan
Susan

July 20, 2015

The outfit is truly beautiful:-) Pink normally looks beautiful on blondes, but I think the hue of the the pink detracts from l her facial features. My eye gravitates to her outfit and not to her face. It should have been more of a pastel like peach and sage, or periwinkle, or baby blue. Truly me doll# 62, the color is very striking with her skin tone. So I vote for Truly me.

Diana D
Diana D

July 20, 2015

I think pink looks better on blondes. I voted for Caroline.

Ellie
Ellie

July 20, 2015

Gotta vote for Caroline.

adrienne
adrienne

July 20, 2015

Truely me is a standout for sure with this one!!

JerryR
JerryR

July 20, 2015

I think the Be Forever Caroline models this outfit more beautifully!

Kim
Kim

July 20, 2015

Caroline. I think Caroline looks great in that outfit, the pink really suits her colouring. :)

Marilyn
Marilyn

July 20, 2015

I love the Fuschia on Truly Me #62. I have dark hair and brown eyes and I always got positive comments when I have worn clothing that color or any dark pink shades. It stands out beautifully on her.

Lisa
Lisa

July 20, 2015

It looks better on the Truly Me doll.

SKW
SKW

July 20, 2015

Truly Me makes the colors pop. Caroline’s golden blonde hair and lighter skin tone makes her look washed out. “Gotta know your ’season”, baby!"

d
d

July 20, 2015

Caroline – pink goes well with her coloring!

Peggy Afner
Peggy Afner

July 20, 2015

Truely me. She’s beautiful and she wears those colors so well.

Krissy Shively
Krissy Shively

July 20, 2015

You make this soooooo hard! But I have to go with #62!!!

CAROLYN
CAROLYN

July 20, 2015

Beforever Caroline Abbott

Jaynee
Jaynee

July 20, 2015

Vote is for Caroline!

carol
carol

July 20, 2015

And the winner is……CAROLINE! Her lighter coloring goes so well with the pink and the dark blue stripes.

Amy Kelsey
Amy Kelsey

July 20, 2015

Caroline

Shirley
Shirley

July 20, 2015

Caroline. I love the name, the blond hair, and the outfit!

Norma
Norma

July 20, 2015

Both dolls are beautiful and the outfits looks great on each one, but Truly me #62 has that "hey guys look at me I’m really gorgeous stance and her eyes says it all, they sparkle!

Beverly
Beverly

July 20, 2015

My vote goes to Caroline. I think pink suits her coloring best.

Susan Vergis
Susan Vergis

July 20, 2015

I think that Caroline looks best in these colours and style. Truly beautiful.

Kris
Kris

July 20, 2015

I love the out.fit on Caroline.

Jean
Jean

July 20, 2015

Caroline by far wears this outfit best! Her beautiful wavy blonde hair, and beautiful blue eyes stand out with this top of 2shades of purple, and this max skirt of black and white. If I didn not know better I would say she is a princess. She looks a lot like my grand daughter.

Mickie A.
Mickie A.

July 20, 2015

Tough decision they both look great but I go with Caroline

Brandyn
Brandyn

July 20, 2015

TrulyMe #62 looks just adorable!

Lisa
Lisa

July 20, 2015

Caroline
Gail Beam
Gail Beam

July 20, 2015

I vote for Truly Me. Her brown hair and chocolate brown eyes are beautiful and the pink top is perfect for her coloring.

Jamie Bailey
Jamie Bailey

July 20, 2015

I really like the outfit on Caroline. They are a great color combination on her and the outfit really pops. Very cute!!

Sharon Griffitts
Sharon Griffitts

July 20, 2015

Love the Pixie Faire site, the patterns, the contests, the Pixie Packs, classes: all are wonderful. And I love your Africa project. Although I truly love Caroline doll, I think Truly Me 62 models this outfit best.

Jennifer
Jennifer

July 20, 2015

I absolutely love the colors in this outfit. Caroline takes the prize :) sea green eyes pop in this outfit :) hope she wins :)

Sherrill
Sherrill

July 20, 2015

I vote for Caroline. Having had taken classes on color analyzes, pinks are best worn by blondes. Brunettes best wear the royal, bolder colors. Therefore, I vote for Caroline :-)

Anthea Merritt
Anthea Merritt

July 20, 2015

I love the Caroline doll in the outfit! Adorable!

Lynn
Lynn

July 20, 2015

I vote for Caroline. In that outfit she looks like a California surfer.

Marcy Mahle
Marcy Mahle

July 20, 2015

I vote for Carolyn. She looks simply lovely.

Janet
Janet

July 20, 2015

Another fantastic idea! I voted for Caroline because I love the blonde hair with that top, but the other doll looks great in it too.

regina
regina

July 20, 2015

It was close this time for me they both made the out fit look good but Caroline just had that look like this is me this is my style

Leave a comment