Mod Doll Monday (March 13-20th) Who Wears It Best?

Hi everyone,

The question is simple: who wears it best? You vote to help us decide and one lucky participant will receive a 16-inch A Girl For All Time Doll as well as this beautifully crafted dress from Thimbles and Acorns!

 

More About Each Doll:

More About Clementine: Clementine is made from high quality vinyl suitable as both a collector and play doll. You'll be thrilled with the quality of construction. She is 16 inches tall and her head, elbows and knees all move nicely. Her elbows and knees are articulated to allow for a nice range of motion. She is wigged with non-removable cute red hair. Clementine has vibrant inset green eyes with painted and applied eye lashes.

Clementine Your 1940s Girl™ represents the World War II Era. 

More About Lydia: Lydia is made from high quality vinyl suitable as both a collector and play doll. You'll be thrilled with the quality of construction. She is 16 inches tall and her head, elbows and knees all move nicely. Her elbows and knees are articulated to allow for a nice range of motion. She is wigged with non-removable brown hair. Lydia has inset blue eyes with painted and applied eye lashes.

Lydia, Your Georgian Girl™ represents the Georgian era from 1714 to 1830.

 

More About The Limited Edition Sarah Hale Dress: This 1830s dress features a crossed pleated bodice that is set in a narrow waistband. Fitted upper sleeves drop gracefully from the fashionably low shoulderlines. A full lower sleeve spills from the pleated edging of the upper sleeve and fastens at the wrist with a snapped cuff. The full skirt is pleated at the front and gathered in the back. The dress closes in the back with three buttons along the bodice and a snap at the waistband. The dress is designed to fit a 16" A Girl For All Time dolls.

Like the look and want to make your own? This pattern is available for both 16" and 18" dolls:

  

Vote Now & Enter To Win: You enter through the entry form that is embedded on this page and appears just below this paragraph, if you don't see it, be sure to visit the page from your desktop or an alternate browser such as Google Chrome. It may not appear on all mobile devices. The complete rules and entry details appear on the entry form. This is not a comment contest - in other words leaving a comment on the bottom of this page is not an official entry method. The only required entry method is to vote in the poll to help us decide who models it best. The doll with the most votes will be given away with the Limited Edition Thimbles and Acorns Dress. One person will receive one of the dolls and the outfit. You can enter once, or gain multiple entries by completing the other entry methods, and increase your chances of winning. Please review all Terms and Conditions on the giveaway page before entering. While we wish we could run this contest everywhere, for legal reasons it is only open to eligible residents of the U.S. and Canada, not including Rhode Island. This contest is exclusively endorsed by Liberty Jane Clothing and Pixie Faire. Not endorsed by or affiliated with A Girl For All Time®.

a Rafflecopter giveaway

More pictures of each doll:

 

We'd love to hear from you. Leave a comment and tell us - which doll modeled it best! And be sure to thank Shari for giving away such a cute outfit!

Thanks everyone,

The Pixie Faire Team


100 Comments

Deb F
Deb F

March 16, 2017

Clementine models it best. The fabric matches her hair and eyes beautifully.

Cathy
Cathy

March 16, 2017

Lydia wears the dress better. Both are beautiful though.

Candee
Candee

March 16, 2017

The dress looks best on Lydia, by far. Clementine’s short hair throws it off.

Natalina
Natalina

March 16, 2017

Lydia’s wearing this one the best. Love the dress.

Marcie
Marcie

March 16, 2017

Clementine. Both dolls are pretty but Clementine wears it best. I love that era in history and Thimbles and Acorns patterns are great. Thank you so much for this giveaway. I would love to have a AGAT doll.

Toni
Toni

March 16, 2017

A postscript to my first comment:
Thank you, Shari, for sharing your gift. I realize that Lydia was your model for the AGAT pattern, but Clementine just set my imagination in motion. Clementine could find abolitionist writings that mention John England’s school and old Godey’s Lady’s Books in the house where she stays and when she falls asleep, dreams this heroic adventure in America, far from the war-torn British Isles.

Toni
Toni

March 16, 2017

Lydia’s hair makes her look more appropriate, but the outfit is made for Clementine’s coloring, and Sarah Hale partnered with Louis Godey. I can imagine a backstory that calls for Clementine, the merciful girl, to pose as a boy after losing her parents who helped with the Underground Railroad, somehow meeting Sarah Hale, becoming Sarah’s eyes and ears on the street to run errands, and helping to seek information for Godey’s magazine. Imagine Clementine’s being gifted this dress for her dedication and hard work.

Jeannette
Jeannette

March 16, 2017

The dress look best on Clementine because of her coloring. both dolls are beautiful.and thank you for this give-away.

Mary
Mary

March 16, 2017

Definitely Lydia. Girls in the time of this wonderful style never cut their hair unless they had a serious illness. Clementine looks like she is a modern girl dressing up for a Victorian party.

Judy
Judy

March 16, 2017

I think Clementine’s hair, eyes & coloring look better in the dress. It does seem to fit Lydia’s time frame though. I absolutely love both girls & the dress is gorgeous!

Eileen
Eileen

March 16, 2017

Lydia. Wears it best. However those green eyes on Clementine are very pretty.

Kathy
Kathy

March 16, 2017

Clementine

Judy Wall
Judy Wall

March 15, 2017

Clementine as I feel her colouring suits the outfit the best

toogie
toogie

March 15, 2017

Thank you Shari for giving away such a beautiful dress, styled for that era and using fabrics that also have an old world look. Both dolls are lovely. I first clicked on Clementine because of her bright shock of hair. Then I changed my mind, as most girls back then would have had the longer hair. Both are very nice dolls and the clothing is suitable for either. Thank you Pixiefaire for the contest give-a-way.-Toogie

Becky
Becky

March 15, 2017

I don’t know who wears it best, maybe Clementine, but I really like this dress!
Double cute!

Jean Sollars
Jean Sollars

March 15, 2017

It looks nice on both girls, however, I love how the dress
brings out the color of Clementine’s eyes and compliments the color of her hair. My vote is for Clementine.

mee
mee

March 15, 2017

It looks best with Clementine’s short hair but the dress period best jives more with Lydia. It’s close but I’m voting for Clementine because she looks like a rebel who will wear whatever darn period she wants

REBECCA
REBECCA

March 15, 2017

The dress is a beautiful period dress and Lydia has the look to best suit the dress.

Dianna
Dianna

March 15, 2017

I love Clementine’s hair but I think the era of the dress suits Lydia the best.

Diana
Diana

March 15, 2017

The look of the dress fits Lydia best. That dress is adorable!

The_L
The_L

March 15, 2017

Lydia. Definitely Lydia.

Linda
Linda

March 15, 2017

Lydia is the best
Marie
Marie

March 15, 2017

Lydia wears it best. No question about it!! Thank you Shari, the dress is awesome!!

Lynn
Lynn

March 15, 2017

Clementine wears it best, I like that her red hair matches better with the dress.

Linda
Linda

March 15, 2017

My vote goes to Lydia. I love the way this dress looks on her!

Aggie
Aggie

March 15, 2017

I think Lydia wears it the best for the era. I have the pattern but haven’t made it yet.

Rita
Rita

March 15, 2017

These dolls are so very cute. It breaks my heart that my youngest granddaughter, age 10, is beginning to lose the desire to play with dolls. If it wasn’t for her passion for making doll clothes, I don’t know how much she would get her dolls out at all. But she loves making the clothes and can’t get enough of that! Thank you for continuing her time with dolls in any way.

Fran
Fran

March 15, 2017

Clementine, she’s cute and even though I don’t have red hair like the doll, my Dad calls me Clementine everyday!

Joy
Joy

March 15, 2017

I went back and forth, but decided on Lydia. Even though Clementine’s coloring is pretty with the dress, Lydia’s hair and look just make the dress. She is a bit elegant, just like the dress.

Geri
Geri

March 15, 2017

These dollies are both absolutely adorable…as is the lovely dress (and all patterns) created by Shari Fuller! Though selecting a “best” model was extremely difficult, I ultimately voted for Clementine. The pretty colors in the dress fabric perfectly compliment her hair and complexion coloring, and her beautiful green eyes just sparkle in this dress.

Earleen
Earleen

March 15, 2017

Clementine her hair shows off the beautiful neckline.

Karen Pelletier
Karen Pelletier

March 15, 2017

I vote Lydia. they both look good in the dress but Lydia looks more suited to the it. And a big thank you for designing the dress.

Nedra
Nedra

March 15, 2017

I love both!!! I love the long dark hair on Lydia, love that dress on her!

Sandy
Sandy

March 15, 2017

Clementine, because this dress makes her green eyes just pop.

Pat P
Pat P

March 15, 2017

It was a tough choice, but then I thought, ’Oh my darling – Clementine!"

Emily H.
Emily H.

March 15, 2017

I believe that Clementine models the dress just a little bit better because her coloring works better with the colors of the fabric.

Heather
Heather

March 15, 2017

Definitely Clementine. She reminds me so much of my beautiful granddaughter.

Johnnie Allen
Johnnie Allen

March 15, 2017

Both are adorable, but Clementine’s coloring looks best in this dress.

Kathy Keilman
Kathy Keilman

March 15, 2017

I think Clementine wears it best. Thank you for all the fabulous giveaways. Congratulations on 2,000,000 downloads.

Pam McCabe
Pam McCabe

March 15, 2017

I like both the dolls….two hard to pick but Clementine is the best hair and eye color are just lovely..

Janet
Janet

March 15, 2017

Clemintine is best

Valorie
Valorie

March 15, 2017

Lydia wears this gown better because her hair style is more suitable for this era.

Shelley
Shelley

March 15, 2017

They are both adorable. I like the colors on Clementine a little better, but the style is not right for her…she’s a little more feisty and modern. This darling dress is for sweet Lydia. Love this pattern.

Carole
Carole

March 15, 2017

They are both adorable but I think Lydia models it best

JuDee
JuDee

March 15, 2017

Clementine is cute…but I really like Lydia! She is so feminine and yet perky.
The dress is adorable…stylish and the details are beautiful.

Debbie Delcorio
Debbie Delcorio

March 15, 2017

I love clementine in the dress.

Miriam
Miriam

March 15, 2017

I love both but clementine hair colour just suits the green dress more in my lydia is very pretty as well but clementtine gets my vote

Jennifer
Jennifer

March 15, 2017

I love Lydia’s hair with the dress. It seems to compliment the dress, and has a softer look.

Patricia
Patricia

March 15, 2017

Lydia is my favorite. She has such a sweet expression.

Khenemet
Khenemet

March 15, 2017

I love Clemantine, the red sandy hair says it all.

Carol
Carol

March 15, 2017

Clementine has the perfect look for the dress

Wendy
Wendy

March 15, 2017

Somehow this dress just seems to say Clementine. It’s as if after a long day of shopping you try one more dress and a everything falls into place, this is the one! Wearing it makes you feel better, look confident and ‘be yourself’. Hopefully we have all had an outfit that has let us experience all of these – Clementine seems to have.

Judy K
Judy K

March 15, 2017

Lydia, hands down.

Rosaria
Rosaria

March 15, 2017

I think Lydia wears it best.

Patricia
Patricia

March 15, 2017

I love the way both of them look in the dress they are beautiful but I will have to go with Clementine the eye color and hair makes it stand out a little more. Thank you they are just beautiful.

Diane R
Diane R

March 15, 2017

Clementine looks like she’s ready to say “Pick me!” while Lydia looks like she’s thinking “Do you have to take ANOTHER picture!”

Robin
Robin

March 15, 2017

I guess I am a traditionalist. Lydia looks the best!

Jean Marshall
Jean Marshall

March 15, 2017

Very difficult decision but in the end I will go for Lydia

Faye
Faye

March 15, 2017

Clementine, has my vote, she is such a darling.

Julie
Julie

March 15, 2017

I love both but I love the color of the dress on Clementine the best.

Vicki Steward
Vicki Steward

March 15, 2017

Both dolls are amazing but my choice is Lydia.

Charisse
Charisse

March 15, 2017

I love the dress and the fabric!

Anna
Anna

March 15, 2017

The dress is gorgeous and it looks beautiful on both dolls; however, I think Clementine gets my vote given the coloring of the dress, and Clementine’s hair and eye color. Like so many others have said, that dress with her coloring just pops! I do think the long hair on Lydia is more keeping with the era but Clementine is the best model for the dress.

Dinah Snyder
Dinah Snyder

March 15, 2017

Both dolls and the dress are beautiful. If forced to choose one, I would choose Clementine. Thanks for the chance to win!

MaureenT
MaureenT

March 15, 2017

I think Clementine models the dress best because her shorter hair allows you to see more of the dress. The colors in the dress are enhanced with her red hair.

Judy
Judy

March 15, 2017

I vote for Clementine. IMHO, her red hair and green eyes match perfectly with the colors in the dress.

Beverly
Beverly

March 15, 2017

The dress is lovely and they are both so adorable, but I will pick Clementine, just because her uneven stick-straight hair tickles me.

Peg
Peg

March 15, 2017

I vote for Clementine. The colors in the dress enhance her coloring. BTW I would not mind winning her.

Beverly J.
Beverly J.

March 15, 2017

I think the dress looks best on Lydia with the long brown hair.

Lyn Calkins
Lyn Calkins

March 15, 2017

I love Clementine. Her red hair and impish face make me smile.

Leslie
Leslie

March 15, 2017

They are both gorgeous!

Grace
Grace

March 15, 2017

I like Clementine. She depicts the child essence for the dress

AnneC-E
AnneC-E

March 15, 2017

While Lydia has the hair length to match the period Clementine has the coloring. She wears it beautifully.

Birches05
Birches05

March 15, 2017

LOVE this dress, thank you for sharing! I vote for Clementine because I like how her short hair shows off the neckline!

GinniB
GinniB

March 15, 2017

Lydia is an ideal model for this dress with her demure expression and long dark hair and she gets my vote. Clem seats it well, too, with a sort of Jo March take charge kind of at.

Darlene
Darlene

March 15, 2017

Clementine looks the best. Goes great with her hair and eye coloring.

Deborah Miller
Deborah Miller

March 15, 2017

The dress is adorable and would look good on any doll. My favorite of the 2 is clementine. I love her red hair and freckles.

Nancy
Nancy

March 15, 2017

Lydia

Debbie
Debbie

March 15, 2017

I love the dress on both dolls – but my vote is for Clementine! The red hair is a lovely compliment to the green of the dress. I have been admiring this doll for some time now and she is on my wish list so I’m keeping my fingers crossed that I will be the lucky winner. [Said out of the corner of my mouth in a whisper “pick me, pick me”.]

Erica
Erica

March 15, 2017

Lydia definitely looks better in the dress. They are both beautiful dolls. I also love the details in the dress, if only it was my size. Lol.

Suzanne
Suzanne

March 15, 2017

Both girls are beautiful as is the dress…only one vote though…Lydia

Gisele
Gisele

March 15, 2017

I like both dolls but the doll with dark hair makes the rust and green make the dresses come out.

Connie Haugen
Connie Haugen

March 15, 2017

Clementine’s hair color brings out the rust colors in the dress. Very pretty!

Jan Hood
Jan Hood

March 15, 2017

Lydia . I believe she looks the best with the long dark hair

Robin Kilbury
Robin Kilbury

March 15, 2017

Although Clementine is my favorite of the two dolls, I think this dress looks best on Lydia. I like it with her dark hair and dark eyes.

Nancy
Nancy

March 15, 2017

Lydia. The colour of the dress suits her colouring best.

Sue
Sue

March 15, 2017

Lydia is graceful and has beautiful hair, but for the dress era it would have been in an up do.
Clementine’s coloration is highlighted by the olive green of the dress. I love the details in the dress. I think Clementine is the ‘best dressed.’

moira brown
moira brown

March 15, 2017

Lydia for sure. Clem’s eye’s and hair do not mesh with the dress.

MoinVa
MoinVa

March 15, 2017

Clementine!

Her hair is short, allowing the dress details to stand out. And, the fabric of the dress is a complement to her hair color.

Eileen Turner
Eileen Turner

March 15, 2017

I chose Clementine because of her hair, both the coloring and the style seems to bring out the details of the dress. But, both are lovely.

honeychile
honeychile

March 15, 2017

I like the way it looks on Clementine. Just as a practical matter, I like the way her shorter hair reveals and shows off the details of the dress. I was a redhead as a young girl and everyone wanted to dress me in bright kelly green, which I detested. So I also like the more subdued olive print, which also brings out her beautiful eyes.

Madge Mitchell
Madge Mitchell

March 15, 2017

Lydia wears it best!

Marilyn  Elscott
Marilyn Elscott

March 15, 2017

I love Lydia Her long dark hair and dress all go together.

Paula
Paula

March 15, 2017

Lydia has my vote as she is so graceful! Love her!

Detra
Detra

March 15, 2017

Clementine wins my vote! Love her red hair and green eyes!! She brings out the best of the burnt orange in the dress!! <3

Karen
Karen

March 15, 2017

Clementine wears it best. If I had the neckline on me the way Lydia does, I’d be going nuts and tugging at it constantly. On Clementine it lays nicely and would allow the wearer to go on with whatever she chose to do that day. Much as I prefer the long-haired doll, she just doesn’t wear the dress right.

Kathleene
Kathleene

March 15, 2017

Both girls look very cute in the Sarah Hale dress but Clementine wears it the best. With her green eyes she has a look of “child-like innocence”. With her green eyes and red hair the dress color is perfect. The dress is absolutely darling.

Thank you for another great pattern and opportunity to win. Kathleene

Sam
Sam

March 15, 2017

They are both both lovely in this dress, but I chose Lydia.

Patricia
Patricia

March 15, 2017

Clementine! The color of the dress sets off the color of her eyes perfectly!

Andrea L
Andrea L

March 15, 2017

I have to go with Clementine, too. That short red hair of hers just sets off the Sarah Hale dress to perfection.

Leave a comment