Hi everyone,
The question is simple, who wears it best?
This week's Mod Doll Monday contest is featuring a chipper nautical outfit made by Karen Wadsworth of Forever 18 Inches and a cute pair of Janes shoes from Liberty Jane. Be sure to vote to help us decide which doll models it best and be entered into the giveaway to win a doll and the outfit!

More About The Dolls:
Truly Me™ #79: According to the American Girl® website, The 18-inch Truly Me™ doll has a huggable cloth body, eyes that open and close, hair that can be styled, and a movable head and limbs made of smooth vinyl. This doll has a medium skin tone, brown hair, and hazel eyes. She arrives wearing a printed dress with a mesh hem, a zip-front moto jacket with a star zipper pull, and glittery flat shoes.
GOTY Luciana Vega™: According to the American Girl® website, Luciana, the 2018 Girl of the Year™! She's an aspiring astronaut ready to take the next giant leap to Mars. The 18" Luciana doll has warm brown eyes that open and close and straight dark-brown hair that has a bright purple streak near her ear. She has a huggable cloth body, and her movable head and limbs are made of smooth vinyl. She comes with the Luciana paperback book, plus her signature outfit: A cosmic-print dress with attached vibrant red purse belt that she wears to Space Camp, A shiny holographic choker and special red star charm necklace she received as a baby, A pair of holographic lace-up boots.
More About The Outfit: Ahoy Mateys! Your 18" doll will be ready to set sail in this crisp top with removable sailor collar and dickey paired with the Forever 18 Inches nautical skirt. A pair of red Janes completes the outfit.
Make It Today: Like the look and want to make your own? Be sure to check out the Nautical Top & Removable Collar (coming soon), Skirts With Pockets, and Janes patterns...
Vote Now & Enter To Win: You enter through the entry form that is embedded on this page and appears just below this paragraph, if you don't see it, be sure to visit the page from your desktop or an alternate browser such as Google Chrome. It may not appear on all mobile devices. The complete rules and entry details appear on the entry form. This is not a comment contest - in other words leaving a comment on the bottom of this page is not an official entry method. The only required entry method is to vote in the poll to help us decide which look is best. One person will receive the doll and the outfit. You can enter once, or gain multiple entries by completing the other entry methods, and increase your chances of winning. Please review all Terms and Conditions on the giveaway page before entering. While we wish we could run this contest everywhere, for legal reasons it is only open to eligible residents of the U.S. and Canada, not including Rhode Island. This contest is exclusively endorsed by Liberty Jane Clothing and Pixie Faire. Not endorsed by or affiliated with American Girl®.
a Rafflecopter giveaway
More pictures of each doll:




We'd love to hear from you. Leave a comment and tell us - which doll wears it best! And be sure to thank Karen for giving away such a cute outfit!
Thanks, everyone!
The Pixie Faire Team
Luciana gets my vote.
I voted #79. She has a soft look about her, and carries of the outfit very well. I feel I want to hug her and make her mine – even though I’m nearly 67!!!
Luciana with her side-swept bangs looks perfect in this outfit!
This one was a tie. I voted for Luciana, because my daughter loves her. Thank you, Karen!! The outfit is adorable on both of them!!
I like the red, white and blue sailor outfit.
Thanks Karen! They both look absolutely adorable in this sweet outfit, but #79 gets my vote.
I have to go with Luciana she wears it best. Thanks
They are both very beautiful dolls, however my pick is Luciana. I like her brown eyes, pigtails, and her face is a little thinner. A nice doll to have!
I love the outfit and Luciana’s “dog ears” as we used to call them. I even feel like I may have owned/worn an outfit like this in junior high!
Thank you Karen! Luciana rocks this outfit!
The sailor collar is so cute! I love this whole outfit. I’m choosing #79 as her eyes just call out to me
Luciana looks very sweet in the sailer outfit. Setting sail for space! Very, very nice. Thanks.
I love to sew doll clothes, even though I don’t have a doll…yet! Thank you!
Thank you, Karen and Cinnamon! Totally cute! It was a difficult decision, but I had to choose Luciana!
Doll #79 wears it best. She is truly beautiful in this outfit.
I love Luciana, but I have to go with #79 on this one!
Luciana, but that was a hard choice!
I love Luciana in that outfit, so pretty with her dark eyes and hair! Thanks for the giveaway!
Luck looks so pretty. What an adorable outfit!
Thank you Karen and I think Luciana wears it best!
Luciana is my favorite, thanks!
Love the dress on Luciana!
Thank you Karen for a simply adorable outfit!! I have always loved sailor clothes and remember sewing them for my kids!! Although I like the wholesome look to #79, I have to pick Luciana as my favorite!!
Luciana wears it best. Thanks!
I really like #79.
They are both cute in their outfit, but I will have to give my vote to Lucianna. I would be overjoyed to win my very own little girl. I would finally have a little girl to sew for. Thanks for the opportunity to win a little girl.
What doll wouldn’t wear it best? The nautical look is a classic. Thanks for making this available, Karen!
Love the cute red, white, and blue outfits. The red brings out #79’s hazel eyes.
Thank you Cinnamon and Karen. Luciana look best in this outfit, IMHO.
Thank you cinnamon for the lovelt outfit. I think Lucinana wears the outfit much better
Luciana this week. Thanks Karen and Pixie
Fair
Luciana this week. Thanks Karen and Pixie
Fair
Thank you Karen for the adorable outfit and I think Luciana wears it best, her big brown eyes are gorgeous!
Both are adorable, but my pick is Luciana. Real cute outfit!
I just love Lucianna in the dress. Thanks for the chance to win!
Luciana is ready for sailing
They both look adorable, but my vote goes to Luciana.
I voted #79 as she looks so much like my friend’s daughter and would look great on their boat! 😁
thank you for your wonderful offers and I do hope Australians are eligible as I faithfully enter each week with my fingers crossed as I do not have an American girl or boy yet..my girls and Rafael are Our Journey dolls which were available through Toys are Us but have now closed down so lets hope AG’s become popular here Sue PS keep up the great work and thanks for inspiring our creative juices
I visited face book & saw all different variations of fabrics for this outfit on the America 18 inch doll. Which one is best is difficult to choose, but one has it for me doll Luciana.
Thank you for hosting Cinnamon and Karen. We think 79 wears the cute sailor outfit best!
With her coloring, Luciana looks sooooo cute! Thanks, Karen, for the adorable outfit.
They are so close! I like Luciana just a bit better- maybe it’s because she has a name.
This is the cutest outfit. I think it will look beautiful on any of the dolls. I know my grand daughter would love this outfit.
Both are adorable but 79 wore it best. I love the nautical look. I’m a Navy veteran and it seems to be seaworthy to me. Thanks to Karen for giving this outfit away.
The American Girl #79 wears the Nautical Outfit wonderfully. Thank you, Karen, for another GREAT giveaway.
Luciana looks like she is ready for a boat ride in her sailor dress.
I just want to thank all having to do with this site and how generous you all are.
I sewfor Charity and you Bless me. Thank you
Luciana wears it better.
I love how the dark brown eyes, and dark hair enhance the nautical look on Luciana. What a winning combination, thanks for opportunity to receive both gifts.
Love the outfit! I think it looks best on Lucianna.
Thank you to Karen and Cinnamon for the give-a-way. I voted for #79.
I love anything from Karen at Forever 18 Inches! Beautiful outfit—thanks for the chance to win it. I like Luciana this week. Thanks Pixie Faire!
Thank you so much to Karen! This is such a cute outfit! I think #79 looks the best, but I am sure that any doll could rock this look!
The dark blue looks so nice with Luciana’s dark eyes and hair! The skirt detail in particular is exquisite.
I like Lucina the best. Something about the hair. It just goes with the outfit
This was a tough choice both look wonderful in the dress. I picked Luciana in and eeny meeny style.
Gotta be Luciana! cuz my niece wants to be an astronaut!
I like #79 the best. Reminds me of me as a child.
I ❤️❤️❤️ this! The outfit reminds me of outfits I wore when I was young in the early 60s. Luciana has an adorable fresh look to her. Thank you so much for a cute design!
Such a cute outfit. I really do like Luciana in it.
I love the pattern and both doll are adorable but Luciana won me over! Thanks Karen for the outfit and I would love to win it!
I like #79 best. Thank you Karen.
I LIKE LUCIANA
Love this on Luciana. Thank you, Karen and Cinnamon.
I think I liked Luciana wearing the darling outfit. They’re both so cute, it’s hard to decide.
Thank you, Karen
It is adorable, especially on Luciana
Luciana looks so fabulous in this outfit!
I really like number #79, she wears her outfit the best.
Thank you Karen for such an awesome outfit.
I think Truly Me 79’s eyes really pop with this outfit, it is stunning on her!
Thanks, Karen. I think that Luciana wears it best.
An adorable dress on both dolls! Since I had to pick only one, I chose Luciana.
How can one choose. Both are cute
Luciana gets my vote just because something drew my eye to her first. They both look lovely.
I voted for GOTY Luciana Vega™: she looks awesome in the stunning outfit…Thanks Karen and Cinnamon for this awesome give away doll and outfit…God Bless
This is a very cute outfit, especially on Luciana. Thank you so much for giving us a chance to win a lovely doll and outfit.
I picked Luciana.
I choose Luciana.
Luciana is my favorite for this outfit.
Number 79 looks super cute; I think her adorable hair style gives her the edge for me. Great outfit; reminds me of something Kit Kittredge would wear :-)
My vote goes to Luciana because she reminds me of a nautical outfit I had as a child. I love the addition of the red shoes which I unfortunately did not have for my out fit. Wonderful pattern by Karen Wadsworth.
I love #79 in this sweet nautical dress. Thank you Cinnamon and Karen for such a special giveaway!
I love Lucianna’s big eyes they make the outfit sparkle.
Lucianna wears it best. She looks so cute in this sweet outfit. Thanks for the opportunity to win her and the cute outfit.
Luciana. gets my vote.. Thanks for your generous giveaways..:)
I think Luciana’s darker coloring looks better in this nautical outfit.
Oh my! I think I had a dress just like this as a little girl! I voted for Luciana in this adorable dress! I love it!!
I think Luciana wears it best
79 looks so cute in this!
I like Luciana! Thanks!
I voted for luciana!
I like Doll #79 because of her hazel eyes. Very cute outfit this week! Thanks!
Luciana gets my vote. I think she looks slimmer. Both are very cute. Thanks Karen and Pixie
Fair for the great give away.
Luciana gets my vote!
I choose Luciana because to me, she looks more childlike. Both are very nice and a great outfit!
I LOVE the nautical outfit and hope to make it in several colorways. I think it looks best on Luciana.
This time Luciana gets my vote! She is so “nautically” adorable! Rosie
Maureen
September 05, 2018
I like it better on #79.