The question is simple: who wears it best? You vote to help us decide and one lucky participant will receive a 16-inch A Girl For All Time Doll as well as this beautifully crafted dress from Thimbles and Acorns!
More About Each Doll:
Clementine Your 1940s Girl™ represents the World War II Era.
Lydia, Your Georgian Girl™ represents the Georgian era from 1714 to 1830.
More About The Limited Edition Sarah Hale Dress: This 1830s dress features a crossed pleated bodice that is set in a narrow waistband. Fitted upper sleeves drop gracefully from the fashionably low shoulderlines. A full lower sleeve spills from the pleated edging of the upper sleeve and fastens at the wrist with a snapped cuff. The full skirt is pleated at the front and gathered in the back. The dress closes in the back with three buttons along the bodice and a snap at the waistband. The dress is designed to fit a 16" A Girl For All Time dolls.
Like the look and want to make your own? This pattern is available for both 16" and 18" dolls:
Vote Now & Enter To Win: You enter through the entry form that is embedded on this page and appears just below this paragraph, if you don't see it, be sure to visit the page from your desktop or an alternate browser such as Google Chrome. It may not appear on all mobile devices. The complete rules and entry details appear on the entry form. This is not a comment contest - in other words leaving a comment on the bottom of this page is not an official entry method. The only required entry method is to vote in the poll to help us decide who models it best. The doll with the most votes will be given away with the Limited Edition Thimbles and Acorns Dress. One person will receive one of the dolls and the outfit. You can enter once, or gain multiple entries by completing the other entry methods, and increase your chances of winning. Please review all Terms and Conditions on the giveaway page before entering. While we wish we could run this contest everywhere, for legal reasons it is only open to eligible residents of the U.S. and Canada, not including Rhode Island. This contest is exclusively endorsed by Liberty Jane Clothing and Pixie Faire. Not endorsed by or affiliated with A Girl For All Time®.a Rafflecopter giveaway
More pictures of each doll:
We'd love to hear from you. Leave a comment and tell us - which doll modeled it best! And be sure to thank Shari for giving away such a cute outfit!
The Pixie Faire Team
Lydia! I’ve always found Clementine sort of creepy-looking.
Clementine’s green eyes and red hair reflect the fabrics colours beautifully, but I like better the overall impression Lydia makes wearing this dress – probably, because of the very feminine impression in her face. My choice here is Lydia.
Thank you Shari for the opportunity to win your design. I love Clementine in this design and the colors are perfect with her red hair and green eyes.
My daughtersaid Lydia. I believe it’s because the long dark hair like mine.
clementine is my choice!
Lydia is beautiful!
I vote for Clementine!
I like the way it brings your the darkness of Lydia’s hair
The print colors on the dress go best with Clementine’s hair and eye color, she gets my vote.
Lydia is adorable in it just lovely
I agree with previous commenter i like Clementine’s coloring best with the dress but for the timeframe I would not expect a girl to have such short hair so I’m voting for Lydia.
Clementine looks like a “darling” in that dress. It complements her cute red bob hairstyle. Oh MY Darling Clementine!
Clementine. She is a lovely doll and I think the dress fits bet because it is in her era. I really would love to win this doll Clementine. Thank you.
Lydia wears it best. Clementine would win with her beautiful red hair matching, but her hair needs to be longer or have a sleeker cut!
Lydia! Thank you, Shari, it is a beautiful dress and pattern.
Clementine gets my nod. She jyst has a wonderful mystic about her and those eyes!
Very pretty dress pattern for these dolls – just love all the great collection of patterns on Pixie Faire & wish I could afford to buy them all..
Thanks Sheri for the adorable dress.
Beautiful dress Shari! Thank you guys for doing another fun giveaway! I think Lydia models the dress best. She looks stunning.
I love it on Clementine!
I feel Lydia wear the outfit the best, her dark hair coloring brings out the print the best! The dress is really cute and I would love to win a doll like Lydia for my great granddaughter. Thank you again for all the nice, great dolls and outfits you give away!
Lydia, for sure!
I think Clementine is cuter, but Lydia fits the era much better.
I think Lydia because without bangs she looks more like she is from Sarah Hale’s time. Love this dress and thank you Shari. The dress is fabulous.
Clementine is my vote but both are super cute!
This is always a difficult decision, but I think Lydia looks like the gal for this dress. She’s sweet and her long dark locks really frame her face nicely. Thank you for the opportunity to win this doll. Rita
I love the dress on both…..but I vote for Clementine, thanks
Lydia! But Clementine is super cute as well! Thank you!!!!!
Lydia for sure; The dress is perfect with her dark hair.
I believe Lydia wears the dress best… I feel the dress looks too large for Clementine. Hope I win….
I thinks it looks better on Clementme because of her hair color & thinner waist.
Clementine wears it best.
I love the dress on Lydia best.
I LOVE both these dolls, but I believe that Clementine wears this particular dress better with her red hair. I entered the drawing but I don’t have Instagram or Twitter…sorry about that. I am having my 60th birthday next month so I doubt I will be adding anymore “tech” to my life…I have enough electronic gadgets to keep me busy (unless it is a new sewing machine, I NEED one of those.) LOL
While Clementine’s coloring goes better with the dress Lydia’s timeline works better. The red dress might look better on her.
Clementine wears it best. How lucky we are that you shared t his beautiful pattern. Thank you.
I think Lydia wears the dress the best. Her hair is beautiful.
I think Lydia wears the dress the best. Her hair is beautiful.
lovely clementine it was mother’s name, and this dolly is very lovely too
Very hard choice. I think Clementine is very striking in this dress, though.
Love this dress on both dolls! But since I have to choose one, I will pick Lydia. ❤️❤️❤️
Clementine for sure, they are both cute, but Clementine looks like a spunky, has her own mind girl!!! She will wear anything she wants!
I love Lydia in this dress. Her long hair makes her fit the timeline for this lovely dress.
I think the dress color makes Lydia look washed out. Therefore, I think this dress looks much better on Clementine!!!!!
oooo I love that RED HAIR of Mz Clementine!!! Yes, Lydia is beautiful as well, but…there’s just something about that red, and the color in the dress…..
I think both dolls wear it well. However, I think the dress looks better on Lydia because of her long hair. I like the contrast of the dress with the long, black hair.
Both dolls wear the dress so well and I think any doll would look outstanding. I do like Clementine’s hair color and it does seem to complement the dress quite nice.
I think Clementine is built for the dress better, and her hair blends in with her dress so it look better on her
It’s a tough decision. While I am drawn to Clementine because of her coloring, I think Lydia is the better choice. Women of that era had long hair that was either drawn back with a ribbon (rusty orange to compliment the dress) or put up in a bun.
Lydia wears it best! I love the color on Clementine, but this dress is straight out of Lydia’s era and she looks gorgeous in it!
Clementine, Her hair color brings out the shots of color in the dress.
I choose Clementine as looking the best.
Clementine is my pick. Besides coloring, its the overall balance in the hair, shape, dress. I like Lydia too, I think having her hair up or off her neck would take it one step up.
Lydia, fits the time best with the long straight hair. Clementine’s coloring is best for the fabric, but Lydia wins.
I like Clemantine best-especially with that red hair
Lydia looks so striking in this dress.
they are both adorable but my vote goes to Lydia
I love this dress on Lydia. It is perfect for her.
Lydia. Her hair is perfect for the dress style.
I vote Clementine, that red hair just looks better with the colors of the fabric. So cute !
Anna has expressed my thoughts completely,they are both beautiful dolls and it is a wonderful pattern for the time. Clementine’s hair and eye color make this particular fabric pop but Lydia’s hair is much more keeping with the time. Thank you so much for such a beautiful pattern and
My vote goes to Clementine as the dress compliments her hair and eyes so well.
Tough decision, I think the coloring matches Clementine but Lydia’s hair length seems more appropriate to time period of dress.
Clementine is my favorite, with the red hair and green eyes matching the dress
Thanks Shari for the dress and for sharing your talent for design, I think Lydia is right for this period garment. If I win her I need to buy a whole new set of your patterns in her size.
My vote definitely goes to Clementine. Her mid-length red hair and green eyes compliment the colours in the beautifully detailed dress.
Questions of coloring aside, Lydia has the appropriate length hair for the time period represented by this dress (which I love — I have this pattern!). When I do period styles, I attempt to make the hair style and accessories correspond to the epoch represented by the clothing. While I love Clementine’s hair color with the gown, her hair length and style is inappropriate for the style. Unless, that is, she was something like a typhoid victim!
I would have to choose Clementine straight haired girls have to stick together ?. I absolutely love the dress so much detail.
Clementine is my is my favorite doll, but because of the era of the dress the hair would not be the norm. Lydia is of the era, but Clementine reminds me of designer Coco Chanel liberating the ladies with her hair style.
Clementine……..the print picks up her hair color
I really like Clementine in the dress. Although the dress looks great on both dolls.
I think Lydia wears the dress best.
I think Lydia’s long dark hair is a better fit with the dress, but they are both beautiful dolls.
Both dolls look beautiful in this gorgeous dress, but my vote is for Clementine. Her hair colour just matches so great with the colours in this dress.
I have to vote for Clementine since I am the mother of a redhead!
both but it look better in Clementine with short hair you can see of the beautiful detail….thanks…
I find Clementine very beautiful in this dress. It goes with the color of his eyes.
Lydia wears it best as it is more of a romantic pattern and her long hair matches the dress style better
I like very much Clementine and her wonderfull dress
Clementine wears it best. Looks great with her hair color.
I love both dolls but Lydia looks best in this historical gown with her long dark hair complimenting it.
Clementine looks beautiful in this dress. Sarah all your pattern’s are gorgeous, wish I could afford everyone. You are so talented .
I prefer Clémentine and her short hair that clears her neck well. The dress is better enhanced. The details of the dress are more visible and highlighted
While Clementines beautiful stylish hair looks good, the dress calls for a more feminine style that Lydia possesses.
I prefer Clementine and her short hair that clears bin her neck. The dress is better enhanced.
Clementine got it going on. She is rocking that dress. Her simple hair style and green eyes add to the elegance of the dress.
Darling Dress! Lydia is so classy and pretty with her dark hair and beautiful eyes to make the dress pop with the colors! – Both Lydia & Clementine show the dress well! My choice is Lydia!
I liked Clemintine the best
I prefer Lydia wearing the dress
Lydia looks best because of her hair.
I like Lydia best…..
They are both cute but I think clementine looks the best.
I vote for Lydia bUT it’s a beautiful dress on both of the girls.
Thank for this contest and I just love this dress. I would say Lydia
I vote for Lydia. She looks like an illustration from a book of fairy tales, maybe Snow White.
Wow. So beautiful!
March 30, 2017
Clementine makes it pop!